Sunday, December 27

What is a "true" frugal blogger?

I wrote a rather-too-glib post yesterday about spending. I was called on it by an anonymous commenter. I think (s)he had some good points that brought me up short. On the other hand, I also think some of the charges were not entirely accurate.


For example, the iPod Touch we're planning on getting will be entirely through rewards program points, just like Tim's PSP. We won't be paying a dime out of pocket. So I consider that pretty frugal.


There is also the issue of video game purchases. Tim got some birthday money from his mom, which he spent on video games. The rest of the games he gets by trading in old ones.


But junk food? Clothing? Yeah, those are my own screw-ups. I eat too much junk food. I try to only buy with coupons, and I've cut way, way back on how much we get. Still, it accounts for more of our grocery bill than I would like.


And clothing: I got three new shirts that cost $60 after tax. It was a complete indulgence. It wasn't one I felt terribly justified in (though it certainly comes across that way in the post). It would be easy to rationalize it away. For instance, the only clothes I have gotten in the better part of two years were when old ones no longer fit. So this particular expense doesn't come up often. But, the fact is that we're in debt; we're working to get out. So that money could have been used in a much more strategic way.


The main point of the anonymous comment, though, seemed to be that the things I talk about -- iPod Touch, junk food, Cheesecake Factory (where we each get a slice of cake on Tim's birthday) -- did not resonate with "true" frugal bloggers.


Ouch.


I make a couple of missteps during the holiday season, and I'm not a true frugal blogger? I suppose everyone is entitled to his own opinion; but I'd be curious to know exactly what the parameters are for that position.


I proclaimed in one of my first posts that I was not the Martha Stewart of frugality. I can't be. Anyone who has ever wrestled with severe depression can attest to just how hard basic tasks are. (Seriously, why can't I make a call that will take two minutes? I don't know. Some days, it's simply an insurmountable goal.) You add in severe fatigue, and you find your options are more than a little circumscribed.


Perhaps some people believe that I'm using my health conditions to rationalize being less frugal. It's not true, but it's hard to prove a negative. Really, I can try to explain until I'm blue in the face, but it doesn't do much good. People who don't understand depression or chronic fatigue simply can't understand how much it impacts your life. So, to them, I'm malingering.


Whatever you believe or understand, the fact is that there are few people in this world with the exact same situation as you. And so it's easy to believe that a couple of details make all the difference. Of course, sometimes it's true. But a lot of the time it's just wishful thinking. Grass is always greener, etc.


I'm guilty of this line of thinking, too. There have been plenty of times in the past that I've become judgmental. You read enough blogs, enough posts, enough "how I got here" profiles, and it's bound to happen. You get frustrated by all of the benefits that other people have.


Most PF bloggers make a fairly decent living. Many of them are in two-income households -- or have voluntarily become one-income situations. Meanwhile, Tim and I have only once ever hit $40,000 a year combined. A lot of people make that much (or almost that much) with just one salary.


Or how about those couples who got tens of thousands of dollars in debt by buying to their hearts' content? Must be nice. Our debt was earned mainly because our basic expenses exceeded our income. Health conditions are expensive.


Tim also brought $20,000 of defaulted student loans into the relationship. After a year, we had to pay $7,000 for oral surgery and dentures. In and among that, there have been plenty of medical bills. At least $5,000 a year -- though much, much more when we got his oral surgery.


In other words, the grass looks a lot greener on the other side of our fence. Even with all our problems and limitations, we've paid down more than $30,000 in three and a half years. Imagine what we could have done with two full-time salaries!


So, yeah, I get frustrated. And judgmental. I have even been known to get into snobby moods where I dismiss other people as having it easy. I get annoyed by how many more corners I have to cut just to get anything like the results enjoyed by people in more traditional situations.


Then (eventually) I snap out of it. Because this line of thinking isn't fair. People with more money get themselves into more obligations. Tim and I don't have a mortgage or car payments. Until recently, we had free use of a car, without any costs, thanks to a very generous parent. That's quite the little leg-up we had. (Now, we are paying for insurance, car repairs and gas, which has definitely affected our budget.)


And I really shouldn't go casting stones. I'm frugal -- but not to the same degree that my mom is. And she's not as die-hard as people who separate their two-ply toilet paper. Meanwhile, neither of us have a garden to grow food in. So, despite being ardently frugal, we can both be shown up by others.


My point? Everyone has different benchmarks for acceptable frugality. I, for example, have no problem with spending $40-50 for a birthday or anniversary meal. Or the occasional pair of cool t-shirts for $18. (Which is, of course, not the same thing as $60 on clothing.) On the other hand, I also make sure we take advantage of freebies, discounts etc. I milk all of the free birthday offerings I can find.


Most avidly frugal folks cook a lot, often from scratch. It's cheap and it can be far healthier than convenience foods and pre-made fare. But I will probably never cook as much as I would like to. I just don't have the energy or wherewithal to deal with it. Tim's stomach doesn't help matters. It's very finicky. If he tries to eat something he doesn't like, he stomach sends it back from whence it came. So he can't just eat that last bowl of leftovers.


Our solution, then, was to keep a few different convenience foods around. Maybe he can have some canned stew and feel better. Or a hot dog. Or some frozen pizza. So long as we don't end up going to the grocery store (which adds up quickly) or ordering out (which adds up even faster), we've saved a good chunk of money. So, we've found an option that's cheaper than the alternatives. But few people would look at it and proclaim it to be frugal.


Really frugal people go to the store to hit key sales. They do sales, coupons, rebates and Register Rewards. So far, I'm only up to coupons. I do the occasional Register Rewards, but my energy problems mean I'm never sure I can use them before they expire. Meanwhile, rebates are just somehow beyond me. I never get around to mailing them off, no matter how good my intentions are. Eventually, I'll get there. It took me awhile to work up to using coupons; now they're second nature. But, for now, people might decide I'm not trying hard enough in those areas.


Then there are the times that I do something dumb, like fall in love with (and buy) some shirts for $60. There is really no excuse for it. I actually tend to stay out of department stores because of the problem of temptation. This time, though, I didn't. And I paid for it -- quite literally.


I am in the process of trying to find a balance between constantly living for the future -- when the debts are paid off -- and enjoying myself a little in the present. Often, I fall too far onto one side or the other. It's yet another work in progress, and this last shopping spree was a not-so-gentle reminder that I'm not even close to finding the solution.


So, yeah, I'm not a paragon of frugality. But I think I do okay, especially considering my limitations. I certainly think I do better than a lot of people, assuming that counts for anything.


I talk on here about free and/or cheap entertainment. There are the movie passes from My Coke Rewards. I have discussed various rewards and cash-back programs, which allow for big purchases (especially electronics) for free. And I mystery shop to get free dinners or other entertainment. Sometimes, I even make a couple of bucks off the endeavor.


For now, that has to be enough for me. That's not to say, though, that it's enough for other people. We each have our own version of frugality, a standard that seems, to us, right and fair. It's not something you can easily get someone to change. And given my recent talk of spending, I'm not really in a position to argue anything anyway.


I guess I just bristle at the term "true frugal blogger" because I happen to think too much of frugality is a case-by-case basis.


If that's not true, then where do we draw the line? What is the objective basis we use to delineate frugal from non-frugal? How much do you have to save? How much debt must you pay down each month? How much leeway can you give yourself for entertainment or indulgences before you are booted from the club?


And while you consider those questions, remember that I -- who am not a true frugal blogger -- got our debt down by $1,200 (38% of our income) this month. Actually, we paid $1,800 (57% of our income); but $600 of that covered new charges like car repairs and a vet visit for Sandy.


Now, if I can just go back to avoiding department stores, we may be set after all.

Labels: , ,

Sunday, October 4

Getting serious

I've been living frugally for most of my life. That's not to say that I've always been the strict definition of frugality.


My disability certainly made things harder, but particularly being careful with money. Before my mom moved to Seattle, any grocery trip meant a walk. That wasn't always possible. Other times, even preparing food I already had was simply too much to consider.


But, throughout most of my life, I have been acutely aware of my money and how it is spent. I have tried to spend within reason. At times, though, just staying on my medications while uninsured put me in debt every month. Tim brought a lot more money into the equation, though there were more expenses to consider, as well. And we've spent the last 3 years together paying off his oral surgery, his student loans and our combined medical expenses.


So I hope you can appreciate what I mean when I say that we're "getting serious" about our debt reduction efforts.


Of course, we were already planning on making larger payments against our debt, now that we aren't forking over $502 a month to insurance. But we got a nice little spur in our proverbial hindquarters the other day: My contract work may not last much longer. It's a convoluted story, full of "if" and "maybe" and "could," so I won't delve into it. The point is, we don't know how much longer we can count on the extra $900 a month -- almost 1/3 of our monthly income.


I probably have at least another few months for sure. I'm hoping for at least six, which I think is relatively realistic. The kind of changes that may occur would most likely take 3-6 months to get decided, and even then they may not affect the majority of the work I do.


Even so, we have decided on a new goal: $1500 will go to debt each month. That's just over 1/2 of our earnings, so it will be dicey at times. But if we can accomplish this, we should be out of credit card debt in 6 months.


Essentially, we will have money to pay rent, buy groceries, get our prescriptions and have our in-home entertainment of DirecTV and Netflix. Up until we get back into therapy, there will be about $250 of wiggle room. But there are other draining costs to deal with in the meantime. A speeding ticket from our move down will take a chunk. We have some checks to send back to doctors in Seattle. And I need to see a dentist asap about some cavities.


That's not to say we'll be living entirely hand-to-mouth. Currently, we're having to replenish our cupboards, which is always a budget drain. Once we're a little less Old Mother Hubbard, we can scale back on groceries. And that will free up some funds for the occasional meal out. (Emphasis on occasional.)


I've already started preparing Tim for the idea that we'll be buying only sale items, preferably ones we have coupons for. This may sound simplistic, but remember that Tim has severe ADD. He has trouble knowing what he wants until he's in the store, which is to say that his cravings develop as his eyes roam the aisles. An expensive habit, to say the least, but one that he's working on.


It probably goes without saying that more cooking will be important. In the past, it's been a problem because of energy. I frequently lacked the energy to get the ingredients, let alone actually prepare the meal. Part of this was also the depression making small tasks feel overwhelming.


Here in Arizona, though, Tim is doing most of the driving, which frees up a lot of my energy. In addition, the sunshine is helping with my depression. Overall, then, I'm finding it easier to accomplish my daily tasks. That will be huge, when it comes to staying within budget.


Of course, another big boost comes from my determination to use a slow cooker in meal preparation. I find that cooking sounds a lot less onerous if it mainly involves my dumping ingredients into a pot, then coming back 7 hours later and declaring it dinner. I've already had one successful meal through this method. I cobbled together a spicy sauce by grabbing whatever we had on hand and mixing to taste. Then I slathered it on some chicken in the slow cooker and, 6 hours later, it was a tasty entree.


Besides cooking, the biggest obstacle will be not eating while out and about. There are several places in this area that we still consider rare treats. There are few, if any, Dairy Queens in Seattle city limits. But there is one about a mile from our apartment. A couple of blocks from that is a Sonic. Luckily, DQ has a semi-regular buy-one-get-one coupon in Sunday papers, which will allow us an indulgence or two; and Sonic has a daily happy hour that gives us half off their oh-so-tasty drinks. In the end, it will be about strategy rather than total deprivation.


At least, that's what I'm trying to convince Tim. He has been tethered to the apartment, for fear of going for a walk/bike ride and being stranded with hunger pangs. It's a valid enough fear, since most of his food is sugary and/or insubstantial. And in Arizona heat, Quaker bars will become a gooey mess. Luckily, Walgreen's and CVS have both been discounting their canned nuts lately. I pointed out that these would be a good, lasting snack to carry with him in a backpack. He's agreed to give it a try.


If it works, he can go burn off some energy for free as necessary. That will help keep him from being so antsy at night, since that leads to a desire to go out -- which always seems to lead to spending money. As for myself, I'm trying to get back into working out. The fitness center is mere steps away from our door. That should take up any restless feelings I have, as well as getting me closer to my goal of overall health. Gotta love those two-fers.


All this planning, of course, is not to say that I expect success immediately. It will take time for Tim and I to adjust to these strictures. We'll do our best to accomplish the goals, but there will be a learning curve. For this reason, I included some broader expenses than we are currently using. For example, we aren't using all that much gas at present, but I budgeted for $100 per month. In our first month here, we probably used closer to $70 -- and that included a lot of back-and-forth as we looked for home furnishings. And as I mentioned earlier, I budgeted for therapy, even though we're not yet back into that groove.


Still, having these numbers in the budget provides us some much-needed padding. If we come in under budget, it will be a psychological boost. In addition, I hope it will prove to be a source of "fun" money, so that we can go out once in awhile in order to stay sane.


So that's our plan. That's our "getting serious." I wish there were some pithy way to sum it up; some wisdom I could impart to you. But I think I better save any and all wisdom for keeping in budget.

Labels: ,

Saturday, June 27

Sometimes, it's just about making progress

Photo by Andy Carter



Budgets Are Sexy recently asked, How do you measure your own financial success? There were a lot of answers -- and there are probably plenty more that haven't appeared yet. Some people admitted that they measure themselves by their peers, how much debt they pay off, and plenty of others.


I had a slightly different perspective.


For obvious reasons, Tim and I can't measure ourselves against our peers. Most of our friends can work full-time. Few have chronic health problems that create constant medical bills. So it would be a terrible idea for us to compare ourselves to them.


I am often tempted to gauge our success by the amount of debt we pay off. But most months we're lucky to pay off $500. And with that $500 medical bill to pay off and some unexpected expenses (replacement sneakers, clothes that fit, etc), this month will probably be smaller than normal.


So for me, I usually have to concentrate on the fact that we're making any progress at all. It's not easy. There are plenty of times that I'm maddened by how slowly we have to chip away at the debt.


To remind myself that we are making progress, I got a white board awhile ago. This way, whenever we make a payment, I get to physically erase the old total and write the new, lower one down. (It's also a great reminder that the debt exists, when you feel like going on a crazy shopping spree or that LCD TV beckons with its siren song.)


It's a good way to actually feel that we're making a difference. Yeah, the amount of that difference probably won't be anything close to what I'd prefer. But it is cathartic to see that number decrease, however slowly.


How do you measure your financial success? What tricks do you use to keep your debt reduction efforts going strong?

Labels: ,

Wednesday, June 10

How far do you have to go to be frugal?




Custom Tailored by Chase Reeves



On Sunday, I asked how you know you need to trim the budget. Now, I'd like to go yet another step further and tackle the time-old PF question: How far do you have to go to be frugal?


I am confident that this question has no answer -- at least, not one that will fit everyone. Or even close to everyone.


My mom is a pillar of frugality. She goes from store to store with a detailed list and a full coupon holder. She grabs extra coupons from the recycle bin in our hallway -- especially the Albertson's double coupon forms. She also ruthlessly pursues rebates, not just filling them out, but also marking due dates on the calendar, so she can be sure all get sent to her.


Perhaps most impressively, she stocks up in a way that would make most survivalists proud. She has a chest freezer, for when she loads up on great meat and/or bread sales. Tim and I haven't had to buy toilet paper in at least a year. She's always got at least 5 packages on hand at any time. Need a new toothbrush? Out of toothpaste? Go down to Mom's. (She does donate most of these, and deodorant, to various shelters in the area.) I have about 8 bottles of Scrubbing Bubbles and untold boxes of Electrasol.


In short, Tim's and my life would be painfully more expensive without Mom's habits.


By comparison, I could only be called moderately frugal. (And some might even consider that charitable.)

  • We eat out or get delivery more than she does. Mainly, this is when our health isn't good. But not exclusively.
  • We get new clothes when our old ones wear out, rather than shop at thrift stores. (It's hard for me to find things that fit, as I'm rather zaftig. And I doubt Tim's skin could handle trying on used clothes: He's allergic to powder detergent.)
  • My energy keeps me from going to each and every store, though I do my best to only get what's on sale at each place. Still, even if I were healthy, I would probably get the occasional item priced 10 cents more.
  • We have DishTV and even upgraded. While we're easily getting our money's worth, some would argue that, if we really wanted to save money, we'd turn off the TV and read more books. I, of course, would argue that it's not like we can simply go on nature hikes with my energy and Tim's skin/seasonal allergies. But I'm sure there are other ways to find entertainment.
  • We buy popcorn at the movies. I'm trying to un-Pavlov ourselves on this one, especially since most of the popcorn is usually eaten by the first 10 minutes of the film. But, since we don't pay for tickets or soda (yet another shout-out to all-mighty, wonderful Coke Rewards), it is an indulgence that I don't always feel bad about.
  • I don't do rebates -- the fatigue/depression (take your pick) keeps me from being organized enough.
  • I don't make my own cleaners. It's arguably cheaper and better for the environment. It's also something I'm just not up to right now.
  • I like to buy hair salon shampoos/conditioners. I'm sure some of the drug store brands are just as good. But for my curly(ish) hair, I do notice a difference. Though lately, I've been alternating between drug store and hair salon products. And only washing my hair every other day.

Nonetheless, I consider myself frugal. I do extensive comparison shopping and research before any electronics buy. I clip coupons. I sit down with the circulars each week and make lists of different items at different stores. I stock up when there's a sale. I enjoy plenty of frugal activities, such as reading. Other than replacing a 5-year-old pair of pants, the only clothes I bought in over a year were absolutely necessary.


So how can my mother and I both be considered frugal? What is the threshold for living frugally? Is there one?


I think this comes down to the usual basic questions of personal finance: When money is tight or debt is large, how close to the bone do you have to cut? What should you be willing to forgo? When is it time for even the beloved luxureeds should be sent away? (To a farm, where there's lots of land, and they can chase rabbits.)


Is there one, definable moment when the budget should be cut? When paring things down goes from a good idea to a clear mandate?


And if such a point exists, how do you know when you have to cut all necessities? Is it only with a major financial blow, such as job loss or some catastrophe? Is it merely when debt reduction is crawling along at an unsatisfactory pace? For that matter, what is a reasonable pace to pay down debt?


Our debt reduction is going frustratingly slowly, since we can only throw $300-400 each month. It's been awhile since we had a more "normal" income, so honestly I'm not sure what average earners should pay -- if such a term is ever applicable.


I certainly don't advocate cutting all luxuries out. This increases the chance of frugal burnout and financial binges. Obviously, in cases of job loss or other major financial catastrophe, you cut whatever you have to in order to survive. But I'm a big fan of living while you pay down debt, not just surviving.


What do you think? How desperate would you have to be before you'd give up everything not absolutely essential to survival?

Labels: ,

Sunday, May 31

Frugal is SEXY!



To piggyback a bit on my friend J. Money, "Frugal is SEXY!"


Okay, on a first date, it might not be the ultimate turn-on to whip out a coupon (unless you're the one being taken out), but otherwise, frugality is pretty freakin' hot!


Tim has worked his way from spendthrift to frugal! And I gotta tell ya, it's pretty sexy! (Psst, J. Money, you should totally trademark the phrase, so that we all have to use "TM" and pay you money. Talk about budget-friendly!)


When I met Tim, he routinely overdrafted and that wasn't even the end of the fees. When his account stayed in the negative for more than a couple of days, he would get charged a daily $7 thanks the fuzzy, cuddly folks at U.S. Bank (boo! hiss!).


In addition, whenever he saw something he wanted, he got it. He could actually spend his whole paycheck in one day. (Luckily, I wasn't around for that part. I think I'd have fainted dead away. Or thrown up. And throwing up is NOT sexy!)


Over the past three years, though, he's been making huge strides. In fact, lately, he's been outdoing me!


We decided to splurge and see Up in 3D. Problem? Tickets were a whopping $14 each! (hat's $10.50 for the movie and $3.50 for the 3D format, in case you're interested.) Cringe-worthy to say the least.


Thankfully, Tim remembered that our beloved Entertainment Book had coupons for Regal Cinemas. It wasn't huge, but we managed to save $5 total on our entrance. Plus we got free popcorn and free soda, since it was the theater's grand opening.


But the savings don't stop there! Now every time we bite the bullet and pay for a movie at Regal, we'll bring our handy-dandy coupons with us. It will bring ticket prices down to $6.50 (with an extra $1.50 if we want to see a starred attraction). That means a savings of $8 any time we go to a non-AMC theater. Ka-ching!


Of course, this isn't the only time that Tim has shown an interest in saving money. Something just seems to have really clicked lately. He was trying to be diligent before, but it was always an effort. Now I find him saying things like, "I'm just trying to help you not spend money unnecessarily." (How HOT is that?!)


Recently, we were at QFC, and ice cream was on sale for $2.88. Since we were going to Safeway right after, I suggested we get the ice cream there, so it wouldn't melt in the car. I said it was $2.99 there. He said -- get this -- "Well, yeah, but 10 ten cents or so can really add up over time."


It was all I could do to not whirl around, grab him, dip him, and kiss him right there in the frozen foods. On second thought, maybe I should have at least tried: positive reinforcement and all. On third thought, though, I'm not strong enough to dip him; and I don't think there's much positive reinforcement in getting dropped by your wife onto a hard linoleum floor. Romance in the modern age is tough!


Seriously, though, I'm just incredibly impressed by how diligent Tim is being. He and I have started having dialogues about purchases that I don't start. Before he would just listen to what I had to say, nod and then we'd go put the plan into action. Now, he engages me in discussion and helps me brainstorm other ways to save -- or to do without the item entirely.


It's clear he's really gotten into this frugal thing. He's eager to help save money, and even more eager to avoid future debt as much as possible. He even told me that he wants to be able to pay cash when we buy a car.


I'm just so proud of how far he's come on the financial side of things. Sure, some of it is reflected glory, since I have been pushing him. But mostly it's just a testament to his determination and willpower. He has changed -- or at least tamed -- his spending ways. He's started seeing a light at the end of the tunnel: a debt-free life. He's done it for me, but also for himself and mainly for our life together.


It's incredibly sweet and very wonderful. And also pretty durn sexy!

Labels: ,

Sunday, April 19

Someone agrees with me!

Okay, obviously many of you readers have voiced your agreement with my opinions from time to time. And other times have even politely disagreed in ways that were thought-provoking and created an interesting dialogue.



But every so often it's just awesome to have a renowned personal finance writer write about many of the same ideas you've had/written about.



Enter Liz Pulliam Weston, aka the Web's #1 personal finance writer. She was once a coworker of my mom's up at the Anchorage Daily News, before she went back to school and became a PF writer.



Liz makes some statements in her latest piece The 0-Dollar Emergency Fund that pretty much coincide with some points I've made in previous posts.



She discusses the opportunity cost of saving for an emergency fund while you have credit card debt.


It makes no financial sense, for example, to have money sitting in a savings account earning 2% or 3% for years while you have credit card debt accumulating at double-digit rates. Paying down your credit cards not only lowers your interest costs, it also frees up space on your credit lines that you could use again in an emergency.



This is something I discussed in both Why I Won't Save an Emergency Fund and Emergency Fund Vs Debt -- the Eternal Debate.



Of course, I didn't have my arguments as prepared as Liz does. In the first article, I wrote about why it made no sense for Tim and I to save an EF while our credit card debt accrued so much interest. We, however, were speaking from a strangely secure position of financial difficulty. After all, Tim has no job to lose, and unemployment has been extended for the foreseeable future. I have disability payments and contract work that is pretty much assured through September, unless my performance utterly tanks.



Many of you wrote in asking how I proposed other people could pay bills. Truthfully, I hadn't thought the position through past my own situation. I was simply pointing out that there are times when traditional priorities such as an EF are actually detrimental to debt reduction.



Looking at the situation mathematically, it makes more sense to pay down credit card debt now. Then, if emergencies occur, you put them on the card. In the meantime, your balance is lower, thereby accruing less interest -- especially important given the popularity of the double-billing cycle.



But several of you wrote in to remind me that -- duh -- you have things like mortgages that can't go on a card (usually). So what to do? Well, Liz suggests a home equity line of credit. I'll wait for you to finish cringing.



We are all anti-debt. I know. The knee-jerk response is why anyone would want to take out a HELOC. Liz points out that the maintenance costs on such things are very low. The trick is to only use it if necessary, such as in an extended period of unemployment. This and credit cards will help many people stay afloat long after the traditional EF has run dry. Especially as unemployment averages stretch beyond all previous imaginings.



I have only one real fault with this idea: availability. Liz doesn't cover what to do if you're turned down for a HELOC. My guess would be to keep building your credit score up and re-apply. It's something you hope you'll never have to use anyway, so the only real goal is to apply before you need it. Still, credit is still tight, and we're waiting to see if the government's plans will actually get banks to loosen their stranglehold on lending funds.



To be clear, Liz doesn't seem to be saying you should ignore the EF altogether. She's simply reminding us that saving up for an EF may hinder your debt-reduction efforts. In addition, emergency funds may not keep you as safe as you had hoped. When you sit down and crunch the numbers, it makes more sense to throw the money at debt than into a bank.



I'm guessing a lot of people will try to repudiate this advice. Liz is finding cracks in a PF ivory tower. People love their emergency funds because it's soothing to have money in abeyance. It makes them feel less vulnerable, especially in such turbulent times. What's more, it's pretty hard on the ego to go further into debt. When you've worked so hard, for so long, to lower credit card balances, it's disheartening (to say the least!) to charge them up higher.


What do you think? (And feel free to agree with me -- apparently all the cool PF kids are doing it!)

Labels: ,

Friday, January 23

Fun with balance transfers?

Tim and I just performed some mathematical circus acts. We made the numbers sit, stay, roll over and even jump through a (flaming) hoop. Maybe we'll take it on the road.


And as all the most financially savvy folks do, we started this conversation late at night.


Okay, so this is generally a big no-no, but we were both feeling alert. And there's been a looming threat for the last couple of months.


Prologue


Like most Americans, we got a nice little letter in the mail about our credit cards. They weren't cutting our limit. (In fact, our MyPoints card keeps upping the ceiling.) The company was, however, informing us of potential rate hikes. The cap was 31%.


Now, so far, nothing has happened. But given that both the cards we're carrying balances on have APRs of 15%, we decided to go ahead and play the balance transfer game. Here's where things get fun.



The players


We have three credit cards right now:

  • Citi, which I've been paying off monthly, so our new charges don't earn any interest.
  • MyPoints, which has a current balance of just about $5300. (Slightly rounded)
  • Chase, with a current balance of $3300 (slightly rounded). We've been concentrating on it, since the rate could go up at any moment.


The offers


Ideally, MyPoints would offer us a balance transfer, so we could clear out Chase's balance and close the damn thing. (Mom and I each opened one to earn free airline tickets for my and Tim's honeymoon.)


Alas, no such luck. But the other two cards have some good offers:

  • Citi -- 0% until August 2009 or 6.99% until May 2010.
  • Chase -- 0% until September 2009, or 4.99% until January 2011.


Both have a 3% balance transfer fee.



Mapping it out


So I picked up the white board and some handy-dandy markers my mom got me for Christmas ("Same debt -- but now in color!" she wrote). I wrote all three names down. Underneath I wrote balances. Under that balance transfer offers. Under that, end dates for the promotional


Citi MyPoints Chase
$0 $5,300 $3,300
N/A 15.00% 15% (31%?)
6.99%
4.99%
5/1/2010
1/1/2011



Then I started drawing arrows from one card to another, to represent our options for balance transfers. (It quickly started looking like a football coach's playbook.) Then, we just had to go through the steps to evaluate our choices.




1. Short-term vs. long-term


Most balance transfer offers will give you two choices: 0% for a short time (usually 6 months or less) and a low-interest rate for a longer period. Your choice will depend on what your overall goals are, your salary/job, and how you are faring in the world of personal finance.


If you are on track to be out of debt in a short time, 0% may work for you. If you are secure in your job, which I suppose is rare these days, you may feel okay going for a short-term 0%, which allows you to throw everything you have at the principal.


If, however, you're not sure about your job, you may want to choose long-term stability. If you're still in the early to middle stages of debt reduction -- in for the long haul -- you may want to choose the low interest rate.


The main deciding factor, in other words, is just how certain you are that you'll be able to pay it all off before the APR goes back to normal. If you choose 0% and then have a ton of unexpected expenses, you will have to deal with the rate jumping back to a normal level. It can be jarring, not to mention disheartening, to have your rate jump 10-15% and still have a balance.


This may lead to yet another balance transfer offer. Besides the fee, you should also know that your credit score can take a hit from habitual balance transfers.


As for us, we're well aware that our future is uncertain. Tim will get unemployment through April or May. And he is working with the Dept of Vocational Rehabilitation, but they're still in the assessment phase. So he doesn't know what sort of career he wants to have. That means we have no idea if he'll need schooling or whether his potential job market is saturated.


Given how much of our future is a toss-up, we decided a longer-term, low rate was better than a shorter-term 0% rate.



2. What's the effect of a lower rate?


So, the obvious choice would be to take the $5300 from MyPoints and shoot it over to Chase at 4.99%, right?


Wrong.


As I explained to Tim, credit cards like to use little tricks. One of the best ones, of course, is double-cycle billing. But another dastardly one involves balance transfers.


Since our Chase card already has a balance ($3300 at 15%), the new balance transfer offer ($5300 at 4.99%) would actually make it harder for us to pay down debt.


When there is more than one APR on a card, the company applies payments to the balance with the lowest APR. So if, right after the balance transfer completed, we got a windfall and threw $5,000 at the card, our new total would be $300 at 4.99% and $3300 at 15%


Why do they do this? Well, it's simple: They make more money this way. By applying the payments to the lowest-APR balance first, they get to keep more of your balance at the higher interest rate. That means more finance charges for them, which means more debt for you.


So, if we simply transfer the $5300 over to Chase, our current balance will be untouched and grow larger each month. After 9 months, the $3300 will be over $3700. At 12 months, it will be nearly $3900.


Not a good option. Instead, we agreed to send Chase's balance over to Citi at 6.99%.



3. Make sure the math works out in your favor

One of the most important things about a balance transfer, of course, is about saving money. By cutting your interest rate down (or eliminating it) you can put all your funds against the principal. That can mean big savings.


But balance transfers always come with fees. In the best scenarios, there is a cap on the fee. In the past, I have had ones that topped out at $75. Unfortunately, those seem to be increasingly rare. Nowadays most are just a straight 3% of the transferred amount.


So it's important that you do the math. You want the balance transfer to be negated by the interest you save. Personally, I prefer for the equilibrium (fee paid vs interest saved) to come by the third month. But it can be difficult to calculate interest, since your payments may vary paycheck to paycheck, and double-billing cycles can make it hard to accurately predict interest accrual. In the end, you have to find your own comfort zone, and remember that many of these numbers won't be exact.


For us, the Chase-to-Citi transfer would cost just under $100. But on the Chase card, there'd be over $100 in interest by the third month. It made mathematical sense to shift Chase's balance over to Citi.


Frankly, I was all for transferring the MyPoints balance to Citi, as well. That would allow us to close the Chase card once and for all. Tim frowned and studied the white board for a moment. (He's a visual fellow.) He then very gently explained that my idea didn't make good financial sense. After all, 4.99% until 2011 is pretty obviously better than 6.99% until May 2010.


Talk about feeling dumb. Here I was, the financial head of the household, and my knee-jerk reactions were about to cost us money. It was fear pure and simple.


I hate uncertainty, and that's the threat that Chase presented. We don't know if/when the APR will go up. That makes me nervous, which makes me want to just jettison whatever is causing the stress and uncertainty.


Logically, though, my reaction didn't make any sense. Even if the APR did change, we wouldn't be affected, since we would have balances with promotional rates.


In fact, the only way we'd be affected is if the APR changed and if we were late with a payment. I make payments every time Tim or I get paid, so the latter is unlikely -- and it would still depend on the APR having skyrocketed, which still isn't certain.


Once I thought about it more rationally, it seemed like a pretty silly fear. But it was an excellent reminder at how easily our feelings can get in the way of financial decision-making.


With that in mind, we devised a new plan: Transfer the MyPoints balance ($5300) to Chase, where it will be at 4.99%, and then send Chase's balance ($3300) over to Citi, where it will be at 6.99%.


I once again checked the balance-transfer math: It would be around $150 to transfer MyPoints' balance to Chase. But the 10.01% difference in interest rates will make that up in under 6 months. The first month alone we'll save over $40.


We also discussed doing one more transfer, from Citi to Chase, so that everything was at 4.99%. That would save us 2%. But it would also incur another $100 balance transfer fee. And since there will only be $3300 on the Citi card, the 2% is negligible. It would save perhaps $5 a months, if that, and so it would take nearly two years to just make up for the balance transfer fee.


That's a good reminder to always do the math. Sometimes it's more than worth it. Other times, you're just costing yourself money -- money that could be going to debt.



4. Balance transfer timing

Whenever you do a balance transfer, you have to watch the account very closely. If it's close to a statement due date, you'll want to make at least the minimum payment. Otherwise, if the transfer doesn't complete in time, you'll owe a late fee.


As I already mentioned, we currently make payments just about every week. So there's no worries about missing a due date. However, there was another concern about timing.


I was paranoid about doing the transfers simultaneously. Different companies complete them at different speeds. I was worried that the MyPoints-to-Chase transfer would complete first. Then, when Citi completed its transfer, it would ask Chase for $3332. But would Chase give it $3332 from the original balance -- which was my goal -- or would it give up some of the money at the lower, promotional rate?


I decided not to take the chance.


Instead, we're going to simply complete the Chase-to-Citi transfer first. Then we will initiate the MyPoints-to-Chase balance transfer.


Then I can wipe our white board clean and get some pretty colors to represent our new lower-interest balances. After these mental and mathematical gymnastics, it should be a welcome exercise.


What experiences have you had with balance transfers? Did you pay off the balance before the APR reverted? Did your credit score suffer? Would you do another one?

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, January 13

Murphy's Law: 1,764. Us: 0.

This may be a tad disorganized. I'm sleep-deprived -- Restless Leg Syndrome kept me up til 4 a.m. and then woke me up again at 10:30 a.m.


Suffice to say, it's not been a good couple days.


Saturday, I checked our bank balance, and had a nice little heart attack when I discovered we were negative nearly $200.


After a minor bout of apoplexy, I checked the transaction history and found that Tim's health insurance had taken out $502. This was news to us, given that last month the premium was $336.


Sure that it was a mistake, I went to the website to check premiums... And discovered that Tim's rates had been raised by $60ish because he just turned 30. Combine that with the new, 2009 rates ($100 more than last year) and voila, you have an impeccable charge that nevertheless screws us over big time.


Luckily, a relative recently offered us a no-interest loan -- with payments not starting til June. So I zoomed over to the bank and threw the check in the ATM, thereby avoiding about $90 in overdraft fees for that day alone. (Another $60-90 for Sunday/Monday, too.)


Okay, fine, so (more accurately) the title should be Murphy's Law: 1764, Us: 1.


Point is, now we don't get to put the full check amount toward debt, which was disheartening to me. Also, $100 of mine that was in the bank from Christmas, waiting to be spent, was sucked up by the $502 charge.


Meanwhile, on Monday, Tim ran a couple of errands, including going to the bank for quarters for laundry. (He'd used the last one that morning. I skipped a shower so that he wouldn't have to.) Turns out, despite the fact that our relative also banks at WaMu, the check is still being held. According to Tim, they said something about it having to go downtown, since I put it in the ATM and not the night drop box? I don't get it. Nor do I care to.


The upshot is that we have nothing in checking, despite having a ledger balance of nearly $2000.


So I woke up today not just sleep-deprived and seriously considering leg amputation, but also desperately in need of a shower. Seriously, it's a good thing my cat's part Persian, so she can't really smell much. Otherwise she'd be scampering away, yowling in odor-agony.


I went and borrowed some towels from mom so that I can stand to be in the same room as myself. (Yes, you read that right.) And we will probably have to borrow some quarters from her too -- which we can pay back along with the cash I had to borrow from her yesterday for my therapist.


See, it turns out that we're out of checks. Of course, I didn't know this last Monday, when I messed up on the check to my counselor. In case you're wondering, you can mess up a check several ways -- which I have proven in the past -- but this particular time it was by writing the amount of the check on the "Pay To" line.


So, having promised to mail her a corrected check, I get home to discover that's impossible. The next day, Tuesday, we went to the bank and ordered new checks. But, of course, they didn't make it here by yesterday evening. And my balance was rather high, given a few missed sessions from snow and icy conditions. (I grew up in Anchorage. I can drive on snow and ice. But Seattle drivers in those conditions? Terrifying.) So I begged some cash off mom, promising to pay her back as soon as WaMu stops being an idiot. Or, at least, once the check clears.


So, just to recap briefly:

  • Out of towels
  • No laundry money to do towels
  • Very stinky Abby
  • Very exhausted, grumpy Abby thanks to RLS
  • No checking funds available
  • Ledger balance of nearly $2000
  • Check being held, despite being drawn on a WaMu account and being put into another WaMu account.
  • Health premiums up by $156 in the span of 30 days.


The only moderately hope-inducing item in this tale of woe is that the Washington State Health Insurance Pool has a low-income application. If you make sufficiently little, they will give you a discount on your premiums.


I had Tim call and find out whether there was a distinct cut off or if each case was evaluated individually. The operator said they hadn't yet been told the 2009 income cut-offs, but 2008's was $2900.


Given that this is what I thought we were making, I did a little happy dance. Then I froze mid-dance.


My Social Security went up by $46/month. And I had been rounding Tim's unemployment down a bit in my head calling it around $1200 instead of what I now realize is $1364. Add $1364 and $881, you're up to $2245. Now realize that I make $900 a month for my contract work. We're up to $3145.


Of course, since the premiums went up by around $100, chances are that the cutoff rose by around that much. But that would mean I may still have to earn $145 LESS a month, just to save some undetermined amount.


You have to love bureaucratic math.


So, we're going to go ahead and apply, with a letter attached from me saying that we have these debts and list them. Then mention that my work may be getting cut down to $750 or $800 a month. If that lets us qualify, then I'll just have to invoice for less. Assuming the premium goes down by a sufficient amount.


Don't get me wrong, if absolutely necessary, we can pay $502. But it's really a big chunk out of our debt-reduction budget.


And there's always that fun experience of being just over the arbitrarily-determined bureaucratic cut-off. $2899 a month? Sure, of course you can't afford the premiums and here's some help. Poor thing. $2900 a month? Pssht, you'll be fine. Whiner.


Okay, okay. I know the government has to draw the line somewhere. But it's still a very strange concept, when you get right down to it. One dollar either way and you're either indigent or middle-class.


The only thing keeping me going is the idea that, even if we are over the cut-off, there are sometimes loopholes in the system. Provided you appeal enough to the right people. Which I plan to do -- as much as necessary.


For example, when Tim went into the hospital while we were dating, the financial aid people could only count me as a dependent if we were married. So we fibbed a bit and said we were engaged. (A couple of months later, we actually were.) It still didn't really count, since we weren't actually, legally married.


But once we explained that I was on disability and that Tim covered pretty much all expenses other than rent for the two of us, the lady agreed to take that into consideration. We ended up paying nothing for the hospital stay -- which, by a lucky coincidence, is exactly what we could afford at the time.


This kind of stuff just reinforces my very basic belief that there's generally a way around the rules -- so long as you ask repeatedly and are stubborn enough to wait until you get the answer you want.


So, we have had a veritable cavalcade of bad luck, lately. We have a plan to move foward, which helps a little. Meanwhile, we're just trying to get through it and shrug off most of the bad feelings.


I wish I could say that, at the time this all happened, I handled myself with quiet dignity. In fact, I had a mini-meltdown. Just one of those straw-the-broke-the-camel's-back moments. One of those straws being that I lost $100 of money I was supposed to spend on myself. Since the only money left in the account will be loan money, which is supposed to go directly to debt, I was having trouble with the idea of still spending as planned.


Both the lender of this money and Tim have scolded me. They told me it's not my fault the premiums went up. (Perhaps if it had been as a result of my actions, such as an overdraft, they might feel differently. Now they're just telling me to shut up and indulge myself.)


So, I have that to look forward to. In addition, I can always look backward, meaning I can take comfort from the fact that I have been in far worse situations. For example:


I was earning $1200 a month working at a part-time job (quickly digging myself into the hole on energy, no less). My part of the mortgage had just gone up to $600, since I had kicked out a no-good boyfriend. And in a three month span, I experienced the following:


Had the ex threaten me (in the hearing of tenants who then called the cops.) In Washington, if you've lived together, a threat is enough to be arrested for domestic violence and get a one-year restraining order slapped on you.


Three major appliances died. First the stove in the Mother-In-Law apartment downstairs. Replaced for around $350. Then the dryer. Around $300. Then the wall oven/stove top in the main house. That was a little pricier. Had a guy rip out the stovetop/island and put in a stove; take out the wall oven and put in more cabinets. Why, you ask? Because wall ovens start at around $1100.


Right at the end, I secured a full-time job. (I, of course, ended up having to quit from fatigue a couple months later, but at this point I was securly entrenched in denial.)


The last day of training before officially starting the job, I came home to find everyone standing in the street. There had been a fire and everyone had to be evacuated for what turned out to be over a month.


I just listened to the news, shrugged and said, "Well, we were running out of appliances to have break, after all."


It's all about keeping that bitter, ironic sense of humor, I tell ya.

Labels: , , , ,

Tuesday, January 6

Goals or resolutions?


I'm a little late in stating my resolutions for the new year. That's probably because it's been years since I've bothered with New Year's resolutions.


I make goals all year-round. I revise old goals as needed, try to undo bad habits and create new, better ones. Why let the calendar dictate when I try to better myself?


Frankly, I agree with I've Paid For This Twice Already: Resolutions are just goals with a fancier name.


But, you say, surely there's no harm in making resolutions for the new year. It's a blank slate. It's inspiring.


Here's the problem though: There is a difference between resolutions and goals in most people's minds.


Goals are long-term. It's expected that you'll stumble -- you'll succumb to that piece of cake despite the diet, spend too much for the perfect pair of shoes, or have a cigarette on a particularly stressful day. You may not be perfect, but then you're expected to get back up, brush yourself off, and get back on track.


Resolutions, though, seem to be made to be broken. It seems to me that the moment people break a resolution, it's a goner. They toss it away with the pointy hats and noisemakers.


One of my big overall projects is to be nicer to myself. And being nicer means less self-criticism, more understanding. It means giving myself permission to not be perfect. (Please don't misunderstand me: I know quite well I'm not perfect. The trick is in accepting that that's okay.)


In that spirit, I don't want to nail down resolutions that are quickly broken or forgotten. I want to set goals.


Goals are something you work toward. They're fluid and can be changed as needed. And, in my mind, it's far more satisfying to reach a goal than to not break a resolution. One is passive. You're winning by not doing something. The other is active and acknowledges that you put in hard work.


So, while I may not have made any resolutions, I have been pondering some of my goals. Here's what I came up with:



Blog

My ultimate goal is to get to the point where the blog can bring in a reasonable income. That's a long-term goal, though. In the near future, I need to work on increasing my presence in the blogosphere.


So my goal is to have just about doubled my subscribers by this blog's first anniversary. That means 300. As an alternate measure, I want to average 200 visitors per day.


To this end, I have to pay more attention to blog carnivals and actually commenting on more people's blogs, rather than just reading them. I've been slacking in these areas for the past couple of months.



Personal (physical)

I want to lose weight. I probably should quantify this, as vague goals are unmet goals. But right now, between the cold weather, an extra few pounds from tasty holiday treats, and needing new shoes, my knees have been aching pretty frequently.


Not good.


So, I've got two pairs of new shoes. I'm cutting down my calories. And I need to start taking walks again, now that the weather has stopped icing up the roads.


I want to walk every day, but that's not realistic. So let's say that I will walk at least 3 times a week. By the end of January, I want my clothes to be fitting like they used to. By February, I'd like my pants to have a little slack in them. (I don't use pounds because I lift weights. It's hard to track pounds lost when you are adding muscle.) After February, I'll assess how I did and set more weight goals.



Personal (mental)

Tim is working with me to be sure I don't end up completely out of medications. He calls them in for me, when I alert him that they're low. (It's simple, yes, but I procrastinate about it something fierce!)


On the subject of being nicer to myself, I want to continue learning to lighten the hell up. For someone with a pretty good sense of humor, I am pretty damn uptight. And I'm very naturally self-critical. I'm learning (slowly) to give myself room to be human. But my mind still has fun little tricks. One of its favorites, during downtime, is replaying scenes where I messed up or embarrassed myself in some way.


It's exhausting, it gets me nowhere, and it's gotta go! So this year, I will work on erasing that little mechanism, even if it means I have to occasionally say "Stop!" out loud. (I've had to do it in the past. Try explaining that one to someone sitting in the same room without sounding completely insane.)



Financial

Tim's unemployment runs out after May, so it's hard to plan too far into the future. But since we've been able to eradicate $4,000 of debt since mid-June, I'd like to match that for May. Depending on what our tax return is, this may be an easy goal to exceed. But for now, I'm trying not to count too much on any one thing.


So that's it. Those are my big goals for the year. By writing about them, I suppose I've installed you all as my task masters. It's the grand thing about blogging: you get free life coaches.

Now it's your turn: What are you reaching for this year? This quarter? This month?

Labels: , , , ,

Thursday, September 11

WWMHD?

For those of you who haven't heard, OPEC suffered a serious setback today. It planned to cut production to keep oil prices from falling any further. Saudi Arabia walked out. Literally.


The delegates say their country will keep producing at current levels.


Whether or not this has a permanent effect on oil prices, I can't predict. But this move will probably make fuel costs drop in the short-term.


SO:

WWMHD? (What would Mary Hunt do?)


For those of you not familiar with this fabulous lady, she has been running a newsletter, Cheapskate Monthly for years (and years... I remember that my mom was a subscriber back when I was still living at home). Of course, she got with the times at some point and created her website Debt-Proof Living.


(For you die-hard Dave Ramsey followers, you can change it to WWDRD.)


The point is, I'd like everyone to take a moment and consider what you'll do with the extra money.


You probably think I'm being grandiose about a few cents. But it adds up.


According to CNN Money the nationwide price of gas had fallen 44 cents in since July (it was written in late-August). Of course, prices vary by region, but everyone seems to have seen a significant price drop in their area.


So, consider this:

  • At its height, the average gas price was over $4/gallon
  • It's now $3.67
  • Unless you have a very fluid budget, you have set aside enough for $4/gallon
  • What do you do with what's left over?
  • Do you even notice that you have leftover money? Or does it just disappear with a pack of gum here, a soda there, etc?


Let's do the math. Assume that you have a sedan with, say, a 13-gallon tank. For the last two weeks, you've been saving 44 cents per gallon. Even assuming you only fill up once a week, that's $5.72/week. That means you should, by now, have saved almost $15. (And that's not counting the money you saved as prices fell July 17 - August 26!)


So... where's the $15?


Chances are that it got spent without your even noticing. Maybe you get a soda when you go in to pay for the gas. Maybe, now that prices are dropping, you're not being as careful about limiting your driving.


A lot of personal finance bloggers distinguish between saving money and just spending less. Saving money means actually putting it aside somewhere, so that it won't be spent. Spending less means just that: Spending less money than you normally would. If you don't put it aside, it simply gets spent on something else.



Currently, people are spending less on gas. But you have an opportunity to save that money. Yes, it's "just" $5 a week. But that's $20 a month. And you have the opportunity to save it until the price goes back up. (It may, in fact, be quite handy when the prices do climb again.)


And what if Saudi Arabia's actions cause another 5 or 10 cent drop? That would means up to $7 a week, or $28 a month.

That's $28 extra dollars to throw at debt. Or $28 more to earn interest in your account. Or, you can spend it on four meals at a fast food franchise.


Which is more memorable and more rewarding?


I suggest starting a "gas savings" container. Figure out how much you've saved in the past two weeks and put that much in. If you pay with plastic, write a check for the difference. (Since you won't be immediately cashing the checks, this will also be a nice way to pad your account to avoid overdrafts.)


How much will you save in a month? Where would you put that money?

Labels:

Monday, August 11

Why I won't save an emergency fund

I may get a lot of flak for saying this but I think having an emergency fund while you're in debt is a terrible idea.


Most frugal bloggers (and debt reduction plans) stress the importance of saving for an emergency fund while also paying down debt.



The rationale

Once you're out of debt, it's easy to fall back in with just one (even minor) event. A pet gets hit by a car and incurs a hefty vet bill; a kid's growing a little faster than you had planned for; or maybe you have to miss some work and you're out of sick days.


If you don't have an emergency fund (EF) in place, you'll end up financing the costs on the credit card.... And then you're back in the debt loop.


This sounds logical; but is an EF really such a good deal?


Let's say you find out you need $300. If you have an EF fund, you simply take the money out and start building up again. And you probably think that's better than charging the $300, which increases your debt.


But, in fact, an EF really won't make a big difference.



A way around the whole problem


The best way to avoid this pitfall in the first place is to make a payment each payday. Tim and I have done this for months now and it's much easier. The longer money sits in your account, waiting to be paid out, the less you'll inevitably have. A couple small grocery trips, a pizza out with friends and suddenly that extra $100 payment you wanted to make has vanished into the ether.


Additionally, paying your creditors every time you get paid means less chance of late fees and also more flexibility with unexpected expenses. You can simply make a smaller payment for a given month, while using the rest to cover that pricey surprise.


Going this route also means that your money isn't sitting in an account somewhere earning little to no interest, while your credit card balance continues to earn plenty.



Getting back to EFs

But there are times when even this plan doesn't pan out -- often because the unexpected cost times itself to happen right after all your payments have cleared. In which case, you're right back to the emergency-fund or no-emergency-fund question.


Let's assume that you have a credit card with 12% APR, which is 1% a month. You make payments of $400 against your balance, which is currently $5000. Meanwhile, you've been throwing $100 a month into your emergency fund.


So, for those with an emergency fund, your balance wouldn't change. But, because you were using $50 a paycheck to grow your EF, you're making just the $400 payments.


Month 1 Month 2 Month 3
Beg Bal 5000.00 4650.00 4296.50
Payments 400.00 400.00 400.00
Interest 50.00 46.50 42.97
End Bal 4650.00 4296.50 3939.47



















On the other hand, if you threw all your money at debt, things are a little different: Your balance increases by $300, and your payments are $100 more a month.




Month 1 Month 2 Month 3
Beg Bal 5300.00 4853.00 4401.53
Payments 500.00 500.00 500.00
Interest 53.00 48.53 44.02
End Bal 4853.00 4401.53 3945.55
















































So you see, by Month 3, the balances are only $6.08 apart. And the interest paid is only $6.07 cents less for those with an emergency fund. That's a grand total of $12.15 for the trouble of always being sure to pay yourself first and not get the relief of having every possible cent thrown at your debt.


Of course, for some, building an EF is psychologically soothing: You have a safety net. And a lot of debt reduction is about finding what works for you -- whether or not it makes sense to anyone else. So long as your debt goes down, it really doesn't matter what others think.


That makes sense when you're talking about $12.15. But, as time goes on, the disparity gets much more pronounced.


With an EF

Month 4 Month 5 Month 6
3939.47 3578.86 3214.65
400.00 400.00 400.00
39.39 35.79 32.15
3578.86 3214.65 2846.79



Without an EF

Month 4 Month 5 Month 6
3945.55 3485.00 3019.85
500.00 500.00 500.00
39.46 34.85 30.20
3485.00 3019.85 2550.05





Starting in Month 4, the non-EF balance is $93.86 lower. That's almost twice what you're putting away in your fund each month!


By Month 5, the difference in balances has more than doubled: $194.80. And by Month 6, the difference is $296.74.


In fact, with my method, you pay off the credit card debt two months earlier (Month 12 instead of Month 14) -- even if you have another $300 "surprise" somewhere in that time period.


And let's not forget that, even if you put your EF into a "high-yield" account, you're still looking at no more than probably 6% in this economy. Even assuming your card's rate were actually 12% (and they're double that -- or more), that's still a losing proposition.



Caution: Not one size fits all


But I would like to take a moment to point out I'm not issuing an edict. This might not work for certain people. Looking at the numbers, we can make a couple of generalizations:



Throwing all your money at debt is better for you if:

  • The amounts you pay on debt are far enough over and above the minimum due that you can make smaller payments in the case of unexpected expenses.
  • You pay with each paycheck to give yourself added flexibility in dealing with "surprise" costs.
  • You don't get these "surprises" more than two or three times a year.



Having an emergency fund is better for you if

  • You have major unexpected expenses occur four or more times a year.
  • These expenses would mean a significant charge on your cards (if the EF weren't available)
  • You are unable to pay for "surprises" out of pocket and still make the required minimum payments on your debt.



That said...


Regardless of which route you take, you should be wary of too many unexpected expenses in your life. While, of course, you have to account for sheer dumb luck (or lack thereof), generally speaking if there are a lot of financial surprises in your life, that may say more about your budget than the unpredictability of this crazy ole' world.


In other words: You may want to sit down and take another look at your allotment of funds. Are you accounting for everything?


Most of us don't. I often forget gradual things, like wearing out shoes. I can't ever quite account for Tim's doctor co-pays for any given time span, because there will be two weeks without any visits, followed by a MRSA outbreak or eczema flare-up that necessitates anywhere from 2 to 6 appointments. Each with its own $15 co-pay. It just means I had to learn how to be flexible.


So tell me: Do you still think an EF is a good idea? Why?













































































Labels: , ,